Grand Fishknights of Oceania (GAME OVER- Scum and Survival Third Parties WIN)

[Mister Visceral]

Schazer, that ~ATH quote you just pulled up look a hell of a lot like pushing a mislynch, don't it? HMMMM. Unvote

Dini, what you do think about Seastorm?

[Mister Visceral]

Thing is despite the information I could gather I fear of being accused of parroting.

So I am taking a slightly different approach which means you need to check a certain something which I am quoting now.

It's like I have to shove down my own miniclaim down your throats to get even the slightest bit of obvious information.

I saw it. I didn't care. This makes you look awful by the way.

I'm all of a sudded okay with lynching Sinjin now.

[El Ninja Monkey]

Vote:Namboto

That doesn't sound like a town ability at all. I can't think of one situation where it helps town. But it helps scum plenty because they'd be able to narrow down who vigs, cops and docs are.

[Schazer]

Vote:Namboto

That doesn't sound like a town ability at all. I can't think of one situation where it helps town. But it helps scum plenty because they'd be able to narrow down who vigs, cops and docs are.

Dayvig kiiiiiilll it

[Eidolonic]

I wish I could.

Basically, the reason I soft defended Namboto's first post was because it felt like a town type ability to me. You can see who does what, and how they react to them, and help push for lynches that they are. I guess it could be scum so you can shoot those people in the face, too, I suppose. But that wasn't my initial reaction, and isn't now.

The flavorcop thing is nng. I've never been in a game with one, and have no idea what to think about the strawberry ice cream deal/sinjin's mention. (Almost all my experience has been in various hunts).

I'm okay with holding a potato over the fire and seeing if it will panic, though. (I am a horrible person, and I'm so sorry)

Vote: Potato Panic

[Schazer]

Ok Eido, thanks for stopping by. Some more questions.

If Potato flips scum who would you want lynched next?
What if they flip town?
If you think Namboto is town, what is your opinion of people on his lynch wagon? Of the people on his lynch wagon, who would you like dead most?

[Mister Visceral]

Namboto could be 3p as well. Not that we shouldn't get rid of him.

[Mirdini]

Namboto could be 3p as well. Not that we shouldn't get rid of him.

want you dead so badly

potato panic just needs to talk

then I march you straight to the gallows

[Namboto]

List of people I want dead: MV for wine, ENM (vigged) for why haven't we done that yet?, and fF for wagonhopping with no reasoning.

[Mister Visceral]

want you dead so badly

potato panic just needs to talk

then I march you straight to the gallows

If I say "Namboto can be 3p." without any other explanation, then people say "He's trying to push Namboto out of the spotlight." I just can't win. I'm just throwing the possibility out there. To be honest I don't know why I said it. I'm trying to contribute, guys, but it's hard for me to get into this game because blech replacing in. It'll get better as the game goes on though.

Also, what wine? Pretty sure I haven't wined at all over here. I like your obtuseness, but you're going to have to expound on that one.

[Namboto]

Also, what wine? Pretty sure I haven't wined at all over here. I like your obtuseness, but you're going to have to expound on that one.

Your post reeked of "BUT GUISE HE COULD BE X" which, unless I'm defining it wrong, is wine (you're giving occam's razor a good drubbing).

Besides, how does my role make sense as a third party thing at all? What could a third party do with that info? It either benefits town as a whole or scum as a whole, not the person who gathers the info.

[Mirdini]

okay might as well drop what I think right now

sinjin/seastorm feel very likely coaligned

namboto/schazer feel very likely coaligned

MV keeps jumping on lynches but for some reason didn't want to jump on the Namboto lynch until others 'pointed out' Namboto's theoretical scumslips for him and instead voted Potato Panic for as (I believe it was Doofaeus) pointed out just weak-as-heck reasoning. And now he's on Sinjin who as Sotek mentioned feels like town - maybe terrible/not participating town, but town nonetheless.

speaking of sotek

sotek where r u

[50,000 Unstoppable Watts!]

Hi I'm back.

Unvote, no longer feeling this one at all. Can we skip the part where we lynch town to get data and get right to the part where we pin obvscum after the flip and lynch MV pls.

[Mister Visceral]

Hi I'm back.

Unvote, no longer feeling this one at all. Can we skip the part where we lynch town to get data and get right to the part where we pin obvscum after the flip and lynch MV pls.

Cool. Actual words with opinions please.

Your post reeked of "BUT GUISE HE COULD BE X" which, unless I'm defining it wrong, is wine (you're giving occam's razor a good drubbing).

Besides, how does my role make sense as a third party thing at all? What could a third party do with that info? It either benefits town as a whole or scum as a whole, not the person who gathers the info.

The game of mafia subterfuges Occam's Razor into shreds.

[Mister Visceral]

okay might as well drop what I think right now

sinjin/seastorm feel very likely coaligned

namboto/schazer feel very likely coaligned

MV keeps jumping on lynches but for some reason didn't want to jump on the Namboto lynch until others 'pointed out' Namboto's theoretical scumslips for him and instead voted Potato Panic for as (I believe it was Doofaeus) pointed out just weak-as-heck reasoning. And now he's on Sinjin who as Sotek mentioned feels like town - maybe terrible/not participating town, but town nonetheless.

speaking of sotek

sotek where r u

You can say Sinjin feels like town all you want. He still doesn't look like town to me. Scummy actions are scummy actions, and he can't be excused for always being scummy. He does not feel like town.

[armoredSkunk]

what actions of Sinjin's look scummy to you MV?

[Mister Visceral]

Thing is despite the information I could gather I fear of being accused of parroting.

So I am taking a slightly different approach which means you need to check a certain something which I am quoting now.

It's like I have to shove down my own miniclaim down your throats to get even the slightest bit of obvious information.

This entire claim deal makes me not like him. It just seems like a claim that he realized nobody cared about. And he's just trying to be noticed and secretive at the same time. Why would you soft claim and then get mad at people for not reacting to it? Why not be explicit? There are just inconsistencies like these that go on.

Even his first "avoiding bandwagon" vote made me cringe.

[50,000 Unstoppable Watts!]

Cool. Actual words with opinions please.

Here's an opinion.

You're wicked jumpy.

[Laset]

hi dini I was halfway up a climbing wall.

uhhhhh. Well, Namboto looks town now? Like that's a good response to pressure, the claim is a neutral role but the response to pressure is solid. so Unvote from: Namboto.

Could go back to slayer0slot aka Schazer ... except Schazer is doing pretty townish, it looks like?

So we have vote: Potato Panic who looks bad on the wagon and whose posts have, if my memory doesn't fail me, been vibesy for me.

feralFantom's #499 looks really bad to me? Hmm.

Ath ... looks bad in a way that isn't aligned with fF. Ath wanting seastorm dead is hm.

Seastorm is not sticking in my brain this game. I'm really looking forward to compare the seastorm/potato wagons later though like dayumn.

Maybe I'm derping or not tracking well, but why exactly do people dislike MV this game? I don't think he's looking scummy to me? ... I mean he is. But he looks less scummy here than in the other games I've seen him in lately. He's always kinda scummy.



ps: if there is a vig out there - and I would expect there is, there was kind of a lot of death - PLEASE SHOOT ENM. HE IS THE PERFECT VIGSHOT. He claimed survivor, is being antitown, claimed powers from lynch votes. Is probably telling the truth and so we won't even learn anything from a wagon on him because he's so argh.

like seriously every time I see his posts, I go "I WANT THIS GUY D-oh he's enm, ugh".

[Schazer]

Aaaactually I sort of get the feeling Mr Viceral doesn't need looked at most right now. He's sitting on something, yes. It could be anti-town, yes. Regardless, he's getting a paltry 5 on the Moh's Scale of How Hard You're Keeping It In Your Pants, so I suspect we'll find out in an order of a matter of days. Vic, am I right at all?

Seeing as Sinjin and Seastorm are off-limits according to Laset and Dini respectively, I would also be ok wiiith anyone on my "speak out or ship out" list, namely:

Inoxfy
Wateryhell
Watts
Kieros
Eidolonic

These are total nulltell slots tending toward useless. I will currently Vote: Watts because you are here and regardless of what clandestine activities the two of us get up to outside mafia I want his arse on a platter in a completely different way right now.

More experienced than any of the current lynch candidates; no excuse for not knowing what he's doing or at least giving some substantial reads.

[Schazer]

EBWOP In a similar vein Tea and ~ATH are possible additional things once I am done pistol-whipping Watts

[Doofaeus]

Sorry for disappearing yesterday I was helping my girlfriend move apartments.

Namboto has defended himself appropriately and has quite the claim. y_not did state that mafia actually have fakeclaims already? Like a game construct? Interesting. But it looks like no one has anything to oppose Namboto's claim with, Unvote Namboto. We seem have thoroughly examined you.

Would really like to hear more from Potato.

Sotek is freaking adamant about vigging ENM? Something to note, but yeah ENM is more of a nuisance now than anything else. It'll also be interesting to see if ENM's vote thing has been some demented gambit or something, but I doubt it.

MV is flopping around from lynch to lynch, and as Dini stated, he looke me like having a pretty flimsy/nonexistant reason for the Potato vote. Now he's on Sinjin too. I thought Sinjin's post was weird too, almost like he's rolefishing for a cop? but not voteworthy. Do not like (moderately).

ATH kinda jumped in and just kinda joined the Namboto vote (well actually not technically, he didn't vote, I suppose that's something). Didn't like that. Seems to be shooting from the hip this game.

Schazer is acting town and producing a lot of info for a replacemnt, I like it. Skunk is still behaving towny as well. Dini is being helpful and effective.

I'm still really interested in Vote Tea though. Hasn't said anything since my last discussion with him.

(I think this post is less sloppy than my first one, I've had time to mull things over)

[Solaris]

Doing Votals at Reasonable Intervals Edition

========== Lynch
====== Softlynch

====Potato Panic (4) - A Killer Cuppa Tea, Mirdni, Eidolonic, Sotek
===Namboto (3) - Potato Panic, ~ATH, ENM
==seastormjt (2) - FeralFantom, armoredSkunk
=FeralFantom (1) Namobto
=Sinjin (1) Mister Visceral,
=Mister Visceral (1) 50,000 Unstoppable Watts
=50,000 Unstoppable Watts (1) (Schazer)
=A Killer Cuppa Tea (1) Doofaeus

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, 6 to softlynch. The day's deadline will be 12:00 am EST, May 7th.

[Doofaeus]

Schazer has a vote on Watts not Sinjin

[Mister Visceral]

Namboto has defended himself appropriately and has quite the claim. y_not did state that mafia actually have fakeclaims already? Like a game construct? Interesting. But it looks like no one has anything to oppose Namboto's claim with, Unvote Namboto. We seem have thoroughly examined you.

Look at this jump off the wagon. Is anybody else seeing what I'm seeing? Because this looks... really bad.

We seem have thoroughly examined you.

is not something I can see a town saying.