MagicHunt: Game Over! Town wins! Awards!

[seastormjt]

Why the heck did scum shoot him though :/

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Tea: well uh

he was shot by scum.
so, you know. that's a thing.

Oh, wow, really? Damn, fair nuff. (havent finished catching up yet... )

QuickEdit: Altho, that said, ssjt raises a good point: Scum knows their own colour, so they could have bounced a kill off him to alleviate suspicion on him? How suspicious was he before being shot at, anyways?

[Deceptive]

It didn't bounce, he's dead.

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

It didn't bounce, he's dead.

....oh.

...ok.

There goes that theory then? O_o ..but then, why would they shoot him? (also, if hes already dead, why is he in "would not lynch"?)

[Laset]

first posted votal: ++tehPilot, --seastorm, ++visceral, ++limanya, --red.

--red from #143 in retrospect holy balls that looks bad from my current perspective.

huh. given my read on cat, limanya's 159 is actually really good, and nobody is going to follow this logic.
++tehPilot #164, awesome.

okay votal #2:

zatch still sitting with a selfvote is --zatch. --crilly for those nonvotes. --anacreon too. visceral and red look unaligned, heavily so later as I recall. seastorm is super unclear, looking sorta-better-sorta-worse on all fronts, fucking impressive. --thunderjolt.

----zatch for #183, jegus.

I am vaguely amused that #188 made me think badly of both deceptive and druple at the time, and now that I have townreads it makes me think better of both of them.

ugh --crilly. for #200.

Thunderjolt #204 ... is ... pro red, pro MV. that's /interesting/. anti-crilly over vancho? I. ... yeah okay that's Not Coven.

Limanya is anti-crilly. Limanya is looking more and more town.

pala's elects in #219 ... pro-Oz, pro-townleaders, pro-visceral and pro-tehpilot. that's ... deeply weird.

votal #3: No News is No News, although it's mildly --seastorm and --[zatch or visceral], and ... also --crilly.

votal #4: yeah no news at all on this one.

OKAY SO. end of day one, what does the no clue brigade look like?

Won't Lynch:
3. TehPilot
10. ThunderJolt
17. Limanya

No clue:
6. seastormjt
11. Mister Visceral
12. anacreon

Would Lynch:
7. Zatch
9. Red709
19. Crilly

That's sort of too many scum already.

that said, if I ... yeah. yeah, this gives me a perspective again.

Seastorm is likely-FON. MV is probably town. Anacreon is plausible scum, as are Zatch/Red/Crilly/cat/pala/oz.

so too many scums but
for now I'm okay with it?

also: vote: Crilly for only showing up to futility-vote people, hnnnng.

[Laset]

Tea: WNL also includes Vancho, who is also dead. It is my evaluation of /everyone/ because I need townreads to do wagon-analysis and also because there's the necromancer who can bring people back and also it's important to know of dead scum to calibrate estimates.


as for why, I think part of it is that N2 Acio was expressing a belief that paradox was highly town in councilchat which had a silent observer, which is to say a scum. That makes the standard scum strategy of "shoot the guy we think hardest to lynch who will absolutely not be doc-protected" pretty obvious, IMO.

[Zatch]

Perhaps Red chose to kill Paradox but was delayed by Pestilence. Delays are a thing.

[Laset]

zatch

stop being zatch.

[Zatch]

EBWOP: When I said Red, I actually mean Fireball.

[Deceptive]

(also, if hes already dead, why is he in "would not lynch"?)

Revivals yo.

[Red709]

yo tek, tell me what part of #143 is looking bad to you so I can see if I can explain it

[Crilly]

BORING [b]vote:crilly]/b].

Sotek, if you were nature's balance and had to activate in about 30 mins (Or set a conditional on a person for end of day/almost lynched) who would you pick for lynches (please give from one to third preference thank you)

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Acio! What do you think of Sotek's analysis in #555? (I ask you because i dont have D2+3 atm to mould my own thoughts with, but you do.)

[Laset]

yo tek, tell me what part of #143 is looking bad to you so I can see if I can explain it

the anti-vancho is
I don't like the tone of it.

there's being pro-town-leaders-but-with-reservations which is common among scum.

there's also the oz thing which looks bad when oz looks bad.

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Wait, is acio still alive, even? brb, finding a livelist.


Livelist:
Palamedes
TehPilot
Acionyx
Deceptive
seastormjt
Zatch
Druplesnubb
Red709
ThunderJolt
Mister Visceral
anacreon
curiousCat
Sotek/Laset
Limanya
MathgirlPravi
Crilly

Deadlist:
Vancho
SupahKiven
ParadoxGamer
OzTheWizard


Well. If that aint the weirdest death list i ever saw. WTF happened D2 and 3, im actually legitly curious now

[Laset]

crilly: well.

#1 is you obviously, I mean that's where my vote is for a reason.
#2 is Pala.
#3 is Cat. Maybe Cat is #2 because C A T. >_<
yeah actually cat is #2 and Pala is #3.

[Crilly]

crilly: well.

#1 is you obviously, I mean that's where my vote is for a reason.
#2 is Pala.
#3 is Cat. Maybe Cat is #2 because C A T. >_<
yeah actually cat is #2 and Pala is #3.

Now assume I'm actually claiming (which I am, if that wasn't EXTREMELY CLEAR) and give my a second 3 (I assume you'd just move the list up one if I can't be on it and add 3)

Tea, I'd like you to answer it, if you would.

[Deceptive]

God fucking damn it crilly. With one vote on you, really?

[Deceptive]

Like I read that post and my first thought was is crilly claiming but then I thought naww, no way.

[Crilly]

God fucking damn it crilly. With one vote on you, really?

I will probably be too busy to play in a few days, and to be honest, was I not going to be lynched today? I have been quite awful. I might as well get something done, and I won't be able to touch this game in 16 minutes anyway so now or never.

[Laset]

oh /o\

well uh

given ogre, I

do we force crilly to go off now or not? We certainly don't vote him. (I am going to: vote: Cat)

but it might be interesting to leave him alone and see if the super-improbable chance of him fakeclaiming as town makes ogre whiff? that'd be ... good.

anyway I think the new #3 is probably Red.

[Deceptive]

You probably weren't. I was about to try and push people to lynch anacreon.

[Laset]

Anacreon, you say? Hmm. Why him? He was pretty neutral for me.

[TehPilot]

Seastorm I feel a hell of a lot better now that she's said things. #483 was a good post, is a very good post, and everyone should think it is good. I don't entirely agree with 100% of her reads, but they're well backed up and I'm going from light scum to light town with my read on her.

Tea is off to a great start, I look forward to more of what he has to say to give me a good, defined read.

Visceral uuhhhhhh. The entire Visceral/Red debacle rather silly. What I'm seeing is two of my more neutral reads, one slightly town and one slightly scum, going at each other. I don't see Visceral's accusation on Red, as putting pressure on other viable lynch targets is an Okay thing to do in my book. While MV did that himself D1, I read it as more of a "HEY GUYS LOOK I'M CASTING SUSPICIONS LOOK AT ME DOING THINGS I AM SO TOWN" and really I am not endeared to him whatsoever.

I do not know how long the wagon is, but I'm certain it's close to the hard limit of 9? Whatever

Deadline Vote: Mister Visceral

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

was I not going to be lynched today?

You were nowhere near the top of my list, for what it matters (and, unlike some, i would msot certainly NOT be happy voting you without being given reasons.)

But now im hella confused. 2 days ago you had Pala as one of your town reads, sotek, what changed? (especially cos, in my reads-as-of-N1, pala is maybe my 4th or 5th strongest town read)

If you're asking me who i'd karkat on, bearing in mind my reads are 2 days old:

1) MV
2) Cat
3) Nooooo idea, honestly, cos my other couple of scum reads are either dead or town lol